Sumários

Practical class 1

14 Maio 2024, 09:00 Manuel João Ramos


Field visit to Feira da Ladra. Observation, and register of non-verbal communication.

Lévi-Strauss in Great Britain, part 2

9 Maio 2024, 16:00 Manuel João Ramos


Seminar: Reading of J. Goody's Domestication of the Savage mind, chapter 1.

Trabalho autónomo:

Reading of J. Goody's Domestication of the Savage mind , chapters 2 and 3.

The Needham / Dumont controversy

8 Maio 2024, 16:00 Manuel João Ramos


The flaws in R. Needham's "binary opposition" (in Reconaissances, Counterpoints and in Politethic opposition) and the absurdity of L. Dumont's "hierarchic opposition" ( Homo hiearachicus) as two possible outcomes of the ambiguity of the Durkheimean model.

Neddham and Dumont reviewed by R. H. Barnes ( Hierarchy without caste) and J. C. Gomes da Silva (L'identité volée): misreadings of Aristote's Catagories and Organon, evocation of Porphiry's platonism in his neo-aristotean proposal, and of Thomas Aquinas' "hiearachic opposition".

The forgotten categorical relations in Aristote: reversibility and ambiguity as essential to an understanding of the dynamics symbolic thought: Luc de Heusch's critical conception of "sacred royalty" in Africa ( Sacrifice dans le religions africaines), and J. C. Gomes da Silva's view on inversion and reversibility (and notes on dialogism from M. Baktine to J. Kristeva).

Trabalho autónomo:

Reading of J. Goody's Domestication of the Savage mind , chapter 1.


Lévi-Strauss in Great Britain

2 Maio 2024, 16:00 Manuel João Ramos


Lévi-Strauss and its British readers: R. Needham, E. Leach and J. Goody

The impact of C. Lévi-Strauss' ideas and writings in the reshaping of British anthropology, criticisms and adoptions of structural methods.

The prominence of the taxonomic principle. Review of the notion of "dual opposition".

R. Needham: from acolyte to critic to censor. A review of his troubled relation with structuralism.

Right and Left: Essays in dual symbolic classification. Readings of R. Needham's defense of the tabular method in the presentation of Meru and Nyoro ethnography.

Trabalho autónomo:

Reading for next class: R. H. Barnes, Hierarchy without caste

Rhetoric and ideology in C. Lévi-Strauss work - continued

24 Abril 2024, 16:00 Manuel João Ramos


The utopian model behind the structural method proposal: analysis of Anthropologie strcturale II (the equalitarian future and the anthropologist's role; the paradigm of the "good savage") and of Structures Élementaires de la parenté (the primal dualist organisation of the Nambikwara).

Reading of Thomas Pavel's Le mirage linguistique: deconstructution of C. L'evi-Strauss' "analysis of myths" and its non-compliance with Trubetzkoy's methodological constraints.

Reading of Boris Wiseman's " Thought and culture: a reading of Claude Lévi-Strauss"

Trabalho autónomo:

Reading for next class:

R. Needham, Right and Left: Essays in dual symbolic classification